Protected Players
| #1 | Brown Bulls | John | #2 | Rage | Justin | #3 | Hitmen | Dan | ||
| C | Jorge Posada | NY | SS | Jimmy Rollins | Phi | 1B | Mark Teixeira | Tex | ||
| SS | Miguel Tejada | Bal | 3B | David Wright | Mets | SS | Hanley Ramirez | Fla | ||
| 1B | Paul Konerko | Chi | OF | Jason Bay | Pit | OF | Lance Berkman | Hou | ||
| P | Dontrell Willis | Fla | P | Justin Verlander | Det | OF | Vladimir Guerrero | LaA | ||
| P | Roy Oswald | Hou | P | Barry Zito | SF | P | Chris Carpenter | Stl | ||
| #4 | Ball Rats | Micah | #5 | Total Package | Darrin | #6 | People's Team | Casey | ||
| 1B | Ryan Howard | Phi | 1B | Albert Pujols | Stl | SS | Michael Young | Tex | ||
| OF | Ichiro Suzuki | Sea | C | Paul LoDuca | Mets | 3B | Andruw Jones | Atl | ||
| 3B | Miguel Cabrera | Fla | 3B | Alex Rodriguez | NY | 2B | Marcus Giles | SD | ||
| P | Brandon Webb | Arz | P | Curt Schilling | Bos | C | Joe Mauer | Min | ||
| P | Roy Halladay | Tor | 2B | Robinson Cano | NY | P | C. C. Sabathia | Cle | ||
| #7 | Team Bring it | Jim | #8 | Warriors | Paul | #9 | Legend Killers | Jerrad | ||
| C | Victor Martinez | Cle | 2B | Chase Utley | Phi | 1B | Derek Lee | Cubs | ||
| 1B | Justin Morneau | Min | SS | Derek Jeter | NY | OF | Alfonso Soriano | Cubs | ||
| OF | Chone Figgins | LaA | 1B | David Ortiz | Bos | SS | Rafael Furcal | LaD | ||
| OF | Grady Sizemore | Cle | P | Johann Santana | Min | OF | Carlos Beltran | Mets | ||
| P | Ben Sheets | Mil | P | Brett Myers | Phi | OF | Carl Crawford | TB | ||
| #10 | Ace Demolition | Mike L. | ||||||||
| 2B | Brian Roberts | Bal | ||||||||
| SS | Jose Reyes | Mets | ||||||||
| OF | Manny Ramirez | Bos | ||||||||
| P | Jake Peavy | SD | ||||||||
| P | Jake Westbrook | Cle |